GWT or JavaFX webpage dilemma


Question

Im trying to resolve following dilemma. I have to develop whole webpage system(with user friendly content management, it should look like very simple Drupal or Joomla) as a project to school. The webpage should have function of adding and removing articles, editing menus, editing whole webpage layout(header position, menu position etc).

Im in phase of deciding which system would be the best for this purpose. I wrote several applications in GWT. It's very quick to develop something, it works on Tomcat etc. So it could be very good adept for this task. But recently I got an idea of writing whole webpage system in JavaFX 2.0 (webpage would open inside the browser).

What is your opinion about this fact ? Should I use JavaFX or GWT? I'm not sure if whole webpage will be quick enough in JavaFX. If the users that will be visiting this page wont have problems with launching this page etc. I havent found any information about this on the internet.

Thanks for your answers :)

1
3
4/8/2012 9:45:55 AM

Accepted Answer

Go for GWT (also consider using Vaadin or SmartGWT). It does not require a Java Virtual Machine to be installed on the client. Also, GWT allows the client to download only small pieces of the application, and not the whole thing.

You cited two Content Management Systems like Drupal and Joomla that are written in PHP, so maybe the best solution for you is a CMS written in java like Alfresco or Magnolia.

5
3/4/2015 8:06:09 PM

GWT

GWT follows a most innovative approach: you write the entire application in Java. But it’s executed in Javascript. A good portion of your code is cross-compiled to Javascript and uploaded to the client. Judging from the presentations I’ve seen, this approach works surprisingly good. In former times the GWT compiler used to be slow, but today, they seem to have solved (or at least alleviated) the problem. As far as I can see, GWT is an excellent choice

javafx

JavaFX 2.0 is a pretty new GUI framework. So expect a few glitches. The good news is that it’s likely to improve over the years. And I suppose people will start to write JavaFX component frameworks if JavaFX is going to be popular. There’s a video showing the domain of JavaFX very clearly. Container terminal monitoring with 3D JavaFX Source


Licensed under: CC-BY-SA with attribution
Not affiliated with: Stack Overflow
Icon